Best MM2 Weapons to Collect: Knives, Guns and Godlys Explained

The best MM2 weapons to collect depend on what you want your inventory to look like. Candy makes sense for a Christmas theme. Luger suits someone who prefers a classic gold gun. Harvester and Icepiercer offer a more distinctive crossbow silhouette, but they belong to the Ancient category rather than Godly.

Those differences matter more than copying somebody else’s most expensive inventory. A useful collection starts with weapons you enjoy equipping, then considers rarity, availability, and the offers other players are actually making. Here is how to turn a long wishlist into a few worthwhile targets.

Choose a collection goal first

For a first matching set, consider Candy and Sugar. For a standalone gun, start by comparing Luger with your existing knife. If you want an Ancient centrepiece, shortlist Harvester or Icepiercer and decide which style you prefer before committing your trading inventory.

Once you know the exact item, U7BUY’s MM2 Shop lets you compare available weapon and set listings. Check whether you are looking at one weapon, a complete set, or a particular variant. Similar names do not mean identical contents.

Your first goal can be small. One knife and one gun that work together often make a more satisfying loadout than several unrelated purchases. Leave room to change direction as you discover which items you actually use.

Understand weapon types before comparing rarity

Knife and gun describe the equipment category; Godly describes rarity. An item can therefore be a Godly knife or a Godly gun. Ancient is another rarity category, while Chroma identifies a distinct colour-changing version of certain weapons.

The official Murder Mystery 2 game page explains the round’s roles: the Murderer eliminates players, while the Sheriff can stop the Murderer. Collecting belongs alongside that gameplay loop. Choose a skin for its appearance and collection appeal rather than assuming an expensive item guarantees better results.

For the broader classification system, Goomba Stomp’s MM2 weapon rarity guide provides a useful introduction. When choosing an individual weapon, go further than its tier. Two items with the same rarity can attract very different offers.

Knives worth putting on your shortlist

Candy suits collectors who want a clear theme. This Godly knife resembles a red and white candy cane, making its Christmas identity immediately visible. It is a sensible starting point if you want a collection built around seasonal designs rather than unrelated premium items.

Candy also gives you an obvious second target: Sugar, its matching Godly gun. You can collect the knife first and add the gun later. Before choosing a set listing, compare the total with separate listings and confirm that both named items are included.

Icebreaker offers an Ancient knife alternative. Consider it if you want your knife slot to be the focus of the collection. It pairs with the Godly gun Iceblaster, giving you another defined set to work toward. Keep the names straight: Icebreaker, Iceblaster, and Icepiercer are different weapons.

Neither recommendation requires you to complete a set immediately. If you prefer one knife with a gun you already own, keep that combination. A matching label only adds personal value when you like both pieces.

If that is your chosen route, compare the Robux required with your existing balance before deciding whether to buy Robux.

Guns to collect for different styles

Luger is the classic gold option. Its pistol design makes it an easy candidate for collectors who prefer a simpler silhouette. It is a Godly gun, and the standard version should be distinguished from Chroma Luger and other named Luger variants when comparing listings or trades.

Sugar is the natural companion to Candy. Its candy-cane styling makes it especially relevant to someone already collecting the knife. If you prefer the gun on its own, there is no reason to buy the knife simply to satisfy a set name.

Harvester and Icepiercer suit collectors seeking Ancient guns. Harvester has a dark crossbow design with green details and originated in the 2021 Halloween event. Icepiercer came from the 2022 Christmas event and offers a winter-themed crossbow alternative.

Choose between them by appearance first, then compare the cost of obtaining the exact item. Their event histories explain their themes, but do not guarantee that either will rise in value. You also do not need both to build a distinctive inventory.

Compare the targets by collection purpose

Weapon	Type and rarity	Collection fit
Candy	Godly knife	Christmas theme with Sugar
Icebreaker	Ancient knife	Knife centrepiece with Iceblaster
Luger	Godly gun	Classic gold loadout
Sugar	Godly gun	Candy Set or standalone gun
Harvester	Ancient gun	Dark, green crossbow style
Icepiercer	Ancient gun	Winter crossbow style

This is a shortlist by collecting purpose, not a live value ranking. Start with the row that matches your taste, then check whether the current asking price or trade fits your budget.

Separate rarity from value and demand

Rarity tells you which category an item belongs to. Demand concerns how interested players are in obtaining it. Availability concerns whether more copies can still enter through an active acquisition route. These factors interact, but none replaces checking current offers.

Use current community value references as a starting point, then compare actual trade discussions. Notice whether people are offering for an item or repeatedly trying to move it. An ambitious asking offer does not prove that somebody completed a trade at that level.

Keep trade values separate from cash listings and Robux prices. A community reference number is not automatically a Robux amount or a dollar price. Compare like with like, including the exact variant and whether the offer includes additional weapons.

For a personal collection, you may accept a different deal from someone collecting only to trade again. Decide what the item is worth to you before negotiating, and keep a maximum offer in mind.

Turn your wishlist into a trade plan

Write down the weapons you would keep and the ones you would offer. If Sugar is your next target, decide whether completing the Candy Set matters more than retaining another gun. This makes negotiation easier because you already know which trade would improve your collection and which would simply rearrange it. Avoid adding a favourite weapon just to rescue a deal that has become too expensive.

Check the final trade window carefully. Confirm every item name, variant, and quantity after any change to the offer. When comparing a bundle with individual purchases, total only the pieces you actually want. An extra weapon has little personal value if you would immediately try to exchange it, and finding that next trade may take time.

When Robux belongs in the collecting plan

Robux is relevant when the weapon you want has an active Robux purchase option. The Halloween 2026 event provides a concrete example: Mortal and Immortal are the paid knife and gun, distinct from rewards obtained through Candies, box openings, or crafting. Check the live event shop for the current offer.

Base the amount on the actual weapon or bundle you intend to obtain, and review the product’s delivery terms.

Roblox’s official guide to obtaining Robux explains its purchase and creator earning options. Funding an active shop purchase is a different task from finding a discontinued collectible. Adding Robux does not automatically make an old event weapon available again.

Build a collection you want to keep

Pick one target, confirm its exact version, and choose how you intend to obtain it. For a first themed pair, Candy and Sugar give you a clear direction. For one gun, compare Luger with your preferred outfit. For an Ancient centrepiece, decide between the designs of Harvester and Icepiercer.

Expand only when the next weapon adds something you want. An inventory built around your taste gives you a reason to enjoy each item even when trading demand changes.