Connect with us


Stardew Valley Guide: Should You Pick Mushrooms or Bats?



Stardew Valley

Hey fellow gamers, are you confused about whether to choose mushrooms or bats in Stardew Valley? Don’t worry because we’re here to help you with your decision. Sometimes, it can be overwhelming for new players starting a game like Stardew Valley, where you have to decide between mushrooms and bats.

But before answering your questions, let’s cover everything related to the game, like what Stardew Valley is, how mushrooms and bats work in the game, and more. So, keep reading because by the end, you will have ample knowledge to flex about!

Everything about Stardew Valley:

As mentioned, to make this guide beginner-friendly, we’ll start from the beginning by exploring every aspect of the game. So here are the basic details you’ve been looking for:

Stardew Valley is known as one of the popular games that provide you with a great farming experience in a charming pixelated world, similar to Minecraft but with a farming twist. The best part of this game is that you can create your own farm from scratch, explore the valley, make friends with the locals, uncover secrets and mysteries, and, of course, focus on your farming if that’s your vibe.

Here are some key features of the game that you will love to know:

Farm life simulation:

As expected in a farming game, you can grow crops of your choice, raise animals (not as pets), craft items, and sell your produce. You can also customize your dream farm and house with various decorations and upgrades available in the game.

• Multiplayer mode:

The game offers a fun multiplayer mode where you can invite up to three friends to join you online and work together on your farm. To make it even more entertaining, you can chat, trade, and share resources with other players.

• Character development:

You can customize your character and improve your skills in five areas: farming, mining, combat, fishing, and foraging. You can even choose from different professions that give you special perks and abilities in the game.

• Social interaction:

Stardew Valley offers an array of over 30 unique characters in the town of Pelican Town for you to befriend. You can even date and marry some of them, start a family, and participate in seasonal festivals and events, providing endless social interactions.

• Adventure and exploration:

The game allows you to explore different areas like the mines, where you can fight monsters, find treasures, and collect rare materials, similar to action-adventure games. You can also explore other areas such as the desert, forest, and beach, encountering magical creatures and events that add more mystery to the game.

Now, let’s discuss mushrooms and bats.

What is Mushroom?

Mushrooms are common foraged items in Stardew Valley, found throughout different places in the game during the Fall season. They can be located in the Secret Woods during Spring and Fall, Forest Farm during Summer, and in the Ginger Island mushroom cave. Essentially, they are your regular mushrooms!

What are Bats?

Bats in the game are flying enemies that can approach your character from any direction, so be cautious. But what’s their use? Bats found in the bat cave produce certain mysterious forageable fruits during Spring, Summer, and Fall, including fruits from fruit trees.

These fruits are mainly used for the artisan bundle in the community center and a couple of Bulletin Board bundles. Additionally, they can be used as a food source or given away as gifts to characters in the game.

Stardew Valley: What to Choose – Bats or Mushrooms?

Now, after providing all this information, let’s address the main question: should you choose bats or mushrooms to enhance your gameplay?

To make this choice, you’ll first need to earn 25,000G (the in-game currency). Players can earn this by selling crops or valuable resources and commodities in Stardew Valley. Once you’ve reached this amount, a villager named Demitrius will appear in the morning to offer you the choice between mushrooms and bats.

Now, let’s break down the pros and cons of both options so you can make an informed decision:

Mushrooms: Pros and Cons:


• As we’ve mentioned, mushrooms are essential ingredients for the community center bundles.

• You can use them to create Life Elixir, a valuable in-game item.

• They provide a source of passive income, requiring minimal effort to maintain.


• Players can obtain all the items available without going into the cave, and it’s not too difficult to find these common mushrooms.

• Common Mushrooms, which make up about 70% of the yield, aren’t particularly valuable.

So, choosing the mushroom cave will grant a steady supply of mushrooms for a lifetime. These mushrooms are valuable for completing the community center bundles and can be a consistent source of income, providing you with six mushrooms every 1-2 days, depending on how much you invest in the game.

Bats: Pros and Cons:


• Bats are excellent for obtaining rare community center bundle items in the game.

• When combined with the Botanist Profession and Preserve Jars, they can generate a substantial income.

• Bats provide a nearly 50% chance of obtaining valuable fruit on your farm each day.

• They can also provide unique and valuable gifts for characters in the game.


• If you are trying to get stuff for the community center it will totally depend on your luck.

• In case you get common stuff like rocks and wood it will not make as much money as you get through mushrooms.

• lastly you need to be consistent and take care of it every day.

These aren’t your typical bats; they’re Fruit Bats that drop a diverse range of fruits in the cave, adding an exciting twist to your farm. You can discover different types of fruit almost every day, with the chance decreasing if you don’t pick the fruit by day’s end.

Wrapping Up:

In conclusion, your choice between mushrooms and bats will depend on factors like your level of commitment, long-term planning for your cave, and the importance of completing the community center for you. If you want a more straightforward path, you can swiftly finish community center requirements by choosing the Bat Cave.

The reason is simple: the fruit items needed for bundles are generally more challenging to obtain than mushrooms and are rarer. On the other hand, selecting the Mushroom Cave is a better long-term choice if you’re willing to put in the effort, making it an easier choice for beginners. All you need is consistency!

So, now it’s up to you how you approach the game and get the most out of it. Happy gaming, and thanks for reading!

Another interesting guide: Escape from Tarkov Quest Items to Keep