To Be a Master: Which Pokemon Game is Best?

4. Pokémon Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum (Generation Four)

If nostalgia was taken in to account, this generation would have ranked higher on my list, as it represents one of my favorite periods in Pokémon history. Making itself right at home on the Nintendo DS, the fourth generation of Pokémon is the first main series Pokémon game to feature 3D graphics, though paired with Pokémon’s signature sprites. With less sprite animation than the fifth generation, these are some of the crispest and clearest in-game Pokémon pictures, and definitely the sprites at their pinnacle. Taking advantage of the DS’ signature feature, Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum utilize the bonus touchscreen by implementing the Pokémon Watch, or Poketch for short. Outside of operating as a watch (very beneficial with the return and expansion of the day, night system), the Poketch also operates as a pedometer, friendship checker, daycare checker, markable map, and twenty other apps, making it immensely helpful while remaining brilliantly simple to use. Utilizing the DS’ online capabilities, the fourth generation marks the first time players can connect with friends online via Wi-Fi. Players can also connect wirelessly and play together in the Sinnoh region Underground, a surprisingly enjoyable diversion which sees the return of the third generation’s Secret Bases. Unlike the Secret Base mechanic in the third game, which were random points on the map where a player could build a base, Secret Bases in the fourth generation can be similarly decorated with Pokémon goods, but are hidden anywhere within a large “underground” map. Players can come in to contact with one another in the Underground, and finding another player’s Secret Base and capturing their flag (which involves clicking on it and then returning to your base) allows for further expansion of your own base. Players can even set hidden traps for one another to keep friends from reaching their base, which is probably what makes this mode of play so enjoyable.

Giratina ftw

There’s more than a good reason that Pokémon Diamond and Pearl are the best selling games on the Nintendo DS, the second highest selling console of all time, just under the PS2. Generation four is the first to utilize the equipped-move classification system which separates moves not only by element type, but also whether it is a physical or special attack. This resulted in a new level of complexity and strategy when selecting a Pokémon’s move set and gave true purpose and meaning to statistics such as Attack versus Special Attack. At the forefront of this new classification system are some equally diverse, complex, and well designed fan favorite Pokémon who still impact competitive play to this day, including Lucario and Garchomp. Not only do Diamond, Pearl, and Platinum introduce some of the coolest starters since generation one, but they also completed some evolutionary lines so well and consistently that fans often forget they weren’t always around. Amongst the Pokémon that generation four introduced, making full evolutionary lines relevant again are Roserade, Happiny, Mismagius, Weavile, Yanmega, Gliscor, Gallade, and Dusknoir and many, many others! While some might complain that too many of the fourth generation’s 107 new Pokémon are post-game legendaries, the fact remains that Pearl and Diamond remain playable well after the player confronts the Elite Four, feature some brilliant new Pokémon (including my personal favorite Darkrai!), and are just as fun in 2016 as they were when first introduced in 2006.


In Case You Missed It

Great Moments in Gaming: ‘Cuphead’s King Dice and His Legion of Bosses

Mike Worby

‘A Link to the Past’ Refined a Franchise to Perfection

Renan Fontes

A Simple Reason Why Switch Owners Should Stop Asking for Persona

Francis Kenna

A Brief Tribute to 30 Years of Dr. Mario


Indie Games Spotlight – Horror Meets Nostalgia

Campbell Gill

‘Halo Infinite’ Looks Like Another Misfire for 343

Francis Kenna

One Year of Our Golden Deer – Joe Zieja Talks ‘Fire Emblem’, Claude’s Impact, Being an LGBTQ Icon, ‘Smash Bros.’, and More

Marc Kaliroff

Why We’re Excited About the Latest Shin Megami Tensei News

Katharine Booth

‘Necrobarista’ Serves Up a Heartfelt Tale of Grief and Acceptance

Brent Middleton


Mark January 30, 2016 at 7:14 am

So Donphan is great for being a weird tire elephant, but Blaziken isn’t good because he doesn’t look enough like a chicken? This writer needs to get his stories straight.

Zach March 16, 2016 at 4:28 am

Nah, Diamond us the best total. Personally I hate gen 6, though I do enjoy the new online features… But their new names sucked. Talonflame??? Froakie??? Are these seriously the same guys who named Gengar, Lucario, and Torterra???

Ethan Lee May 9, 2016 at 9:55 pm

Really? Says the one with a mewtwo picture, they put as much name into that just like voltorbs evolution form, Gold and Silver ( or HGSS for me ) is hella better than Diamond.


Leave a Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data. Accept Read More