Connect with us

BFI London Film Festival

‘The Disciple’ is a Savage Satire of Artistic Mediocrity

The struggle of making it to the top has rarely been as acutely observed as in The Disciple, playing at London Film Festival.



London Film Festival 2020

The worst thing any artist can accept is their own mediocrity. No budding artist picks up a guitar or a paintbrush for the first time hoping to have a middling career. But the simple and sad fact is that only the tiniest percentage of creatives ever make it to the top. The Disciple charts the fortunes of one such man, an Indian classical music singer named Sharad (younger self, Arun Dravid; older self, Aditya Modak) with gentle savagery, providing a character portrait that is both deeply wise and darkly comic. 

As a young man, he looks up to his guru as a kind of demigod, even if his improvised singing never seems up to his high standards. He also listens to the lectures of the famous Maai while on his motorcycle — shot in long and meditative takes. She was never recorded performing, but preaches nuggets such as “Indian classical music is an eternal quest” and “your mind has to be unblemished”, connecting the purity of the Raga to broader Hindi spirituality. 

It may have been easy back in the day to focus entirely on your music, and to connect it with your spiritual self — the modern world offers far too many distractions. One juxtaposition in particular (which I won’t ruin here) is masterful in its cutting, bleak humour. The Disciple asks what does it mean to be a classical musician in a world overrun with audience members on their iPhones, mean YouTube comments, and vapid talent shows. 

For newbies to Indian classical music, it might be a hard push at first to recognise what constitutes a “good” or “bad” performance — instead it’s worth paying attention to Sharad’s facial gestures as he either listens to others or performs himself. Both Dravid and Modak give a masterclass in passive acting, making Sharad less the hero of his own story than an everyman facing down a world he simply can’t control. 

Director Chaitanya Tamhane exudes confidence in his handling of the script, allowing images, situations, and the beautiful music to speak for themselves without needing to underline them with flashy cinematic techniques. The unforced passing of time adds to the film’s thematic weight, as Sharan eventually has to figure out who he is; providing a coming-of-age story that lasts well until middle age. 

Despite the differences in musical genre, there are shades of Mia Hansen-Løve’s Eden in The Disciple’s storytelling here, both through the subtle use of locations and the changing of the times. It also shares the subtle, smiling irony of Satyajit Ray‘s Hindi language The Chess Players in its critique of Hindi conventions (one gets the sense that it is not just music that’s being poked at here). While much of the context and conversation is specific to Indian classical music traditions (of which I know nothing) and Hindi culture, the universality and relatability of the story ring true throughout. Sharan may never amount to much, but Tamhane (on his second feature) definitely doesn’t have to worry about the same problem. 

The Disciple plays as part of the London Film Festival, running from 7 -18 October. Learn more via their website.

As far back as he can remember, Redmond Bacon always wanted to be a film critic. To him, being a film critic was better than being President of the United States

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


Ricky Da Conceicao, Founder, Editor-in-Chief
Patrick Murphy, Editor, co-founder
Mike Worby, Managing Editor
Marc Kaliroff, Games Editor, (NXpress Podcast)
Brent Middleton, Indie Games Editor
Campbell Gill, Indie Editor; (NXpress Podcast)
Izsak Barnette, Senior Writer
Renan Fontes, Senior Writer
Mathew Ponthier, Senior Writer
Cameron Daxon, Staff Writer, (NXpress Podcast)
Antonia Haynes, Senior Writer
Christopher Cross, Senior Writer
Tim Maison (Game Boys Podcast)
Ryan Kapioski (Games Boys Podcast)
Alex Aldridge (The Winner is You Podcast)
David Smile (The Winner is You Podcast)
Marty Allen, Staff Writer
Patrick Morris, Staff Writer
Caitlin Wiliams, Staff Writer
Daniel Pinheiro, Staff Writer
Dylan MacDougall, Staff Writer
Michael McKean, Staff Writer
Nicholas Straub, Staff Writer