‘Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’ Review: (Mostly) Smashing Good Fun

by Harry Morris
Published: Last Updated on

To say anticipation has surrounded Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is the understatement of the century. The acclaimed franchise takes the gaming world by storm with each and every entry, and this latest iteration aims to top its predecessors. “Everyone is here!” – Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’s battle cry bellows, rallying its scopious cast under one roof. From Mario to Mewtwo, Snake to Sonic, and Bayonetta to Bowser Jr. – Super Smash Bros. Ultimate dons all seventy-plus old and new characters, hence the ‘ultimate’ bit of its name.

So is it the best in class, or a hodgepodge of quantity over quality?

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a fighting fiesta of Nintendo’s all-stars, mingled with some guests for good measure (on that note, Joker from Persona 5 is on his way as DLC? How crazy-cool is that?!). Fighting is fast, weighty, and responsive, and smash attacks being hold-able for longer is a welcome alteration. Newcomers like Inkling and Ridley fit flawlessly, and the breadth of stages is satisfyingly staggering (over one hundred!). And speaking of stages, the new Stage Morph feature is a highlight, changing from one stage to another mid-battle. There is a lot to sink one’s teeth into, so kicking back with friends for some multiplayer won’t get boring.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’s beating heart is its fighting.

Unfortunately, get ready to tell those friends “Hang on, let me sort these rules out”. Super Smash Bros. Ultimate makes drastic changes to menu mechanics, sacrificing simplicity in favor of clunky complexity. Rather than tweaking rules on the fly from the character selection screen, rulesets must be pre-customized and saved in advance. It’s convoluted, and results in something as straightforward as adding another stock being tedious.

(Also, selecting a stage prior to choosing a character just feels wrong, period.)

Outside of standard smash, there’s an abundance of modes. Squad Strike, Tourney, Special Smash, Classic Mode, Training, Mob Smash, Mii Fighter customization, Adventure, Spirit Board, Collection, Sounds, Replays, Records, Challenges, Tips, Movies, Shop, Online… *pant* did I miss anything? Oh, there’s some amiibo stuff too. It’s mostly a blast, with Squad Strike serving up tremendous tag team fighting, and Classic Mode offering unique twists for each character, but the absence of fan favorites like Break the Targets and Home Run Contest doesn’t go unnoticed, and the loss of Stage Builder is disheartening due to its unrealized potential. Although underdeveloped in Super Smash Bros. Brawl and Super Smash Bros. for Wii U, things could only get better had Stage Builder taken influence from Super Mario Maker’s huge scope and oodles of options.

Despite its successes, there’s something missing in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’s oddball secret weapon is its adventure mode: World of Light. In it, players peruse a massive map and fight opponents with quirky parameters at play. Earthquakes, reversed controls, uncontrollable speed – World of Light mirrors the variables of past titles’ Event Matches. Success nets players Spirits (of which there are many to collect), powering them up. It’s fun at first, but here’s the catch: it’s reeeaaallllllyyy long. However enjoyable Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is at its core, World of Light is spread too thinly. Unlike Super Smash Bros. Brawl’s Subspace Emissary, with its multifarious gameplay and dazzling cutscenes, World of Light is just battle after battle, an exercise in monotony, with only the rare boss offering respite from the repetition.

Despite its successes, there’s something missing in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. Perhaps this is best explained with an analogy, so let’s imagine the Super Smash Bros. games are records from a band:

Super Smash Bros. 64 is the killer debut. It’s humble in scope, but lays strong foundations for the future.

Super Smash Bros. Melee and Super Smash Bros. Brawl are superb follow-ups. They honour the band’s trademark sound, whilst simultaneously propelling said sound forward via successful experiments in songwriting.

Super Smash Bros. for Nintendo 3DS and Wii U is a respectable forth record, but it lacks the innovative ambition of its predecessors. It’s a great listen, but a bit forgettable.

Finally, we come to Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. It’s the long-awaited greatest hits compilation, and whilst it sounds just as good as ever, something’s off. Some of the band’s standout singles aren’t included, and track five, World of Light, is utterly disappointing.

After listening, you write a review discussing your experience and perspective, conscious that the band’s fans will be livid at you for criticizing this acclaimed greatest hits compilation. But hold your horses and put down your pitchforks, because criticisms aside…

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’s beating heart is its fighting, and in this category, it scores top marks. The gargantuan character and stage roster is mind-bogglingly magical, and there’re some awesome new modes and features like the aforementioned Squad Strike and Stage Morph. Yes, aspects of Super Smash Bros. Ultimate leave something to be desired (*cough* World of Light *cough*), and more innovation would’ve been welcome, but when all is said and done, Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is unrivaled as a pickup and play beat ’em up. It’s the most fun one can have with friends, and a roaring celebration of all things Nintendo.

You may also like


Ricky D Fernandes December 9, 2018 - 11:32 am

When you say World of Light’s biggest problem is that it is too long, I can’t help but think that if it were short, the internet would also be upset. I don’t like the grind and I think they could have added more variety and more cutscenes but the length isn’t the real problem. That said, this is a fighting game. People buy smash for that experience and World of Light is simply a bonus feature.

Your review uses a great analogy but here’s the thing… You say:

“Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. It’s the long-awaited greatest hits compilation …. some of the band’s standout singles aren’t included, and track five, World of Light, is utterly disappointing.”

Great analogy but I don’t agree simply because Smash has everyone and almost everything from previous games. It has over 74 fighters, over 300 spirits, 0ver 300 stages and songs and so on…

So what hits are missing? And please don’t say the Stage Builder because that was never, ever good.

Melee will always be the better game when it comes to the competitive scene but this is still an AMAZING GAME in my eyes.

The Stage Morphing alone deserves a 10/10.

Harry Morris December 9, 2018 - 12:17 pm

The problem isn’t that World of Light is long, it’s that its gameplay is so repetitive that its length is unjustifiable. Whilst it is a bonus feature, it’s still a significant part of the single player package in my opinion, so its lack of quality is worth critiquing.

The character and stage roster is amazing, and by far the best thing about Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. However, Break the Targets, Home Run Contest, and the Stage Builder (which was poor in prior releases, but showed potential, especially after Super Mario Maker proved how fun creating stages could be when done right) are sorely missed.

Melee is great, but Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is objectively a better competitive game due to its myriad of options and pristine polish. Melee is fun and nostalgic, but is beaten by Ultimate in the core gameplay department.

Being critical of a game doesn’t mean I dislike it. I adore Super Smash Bros. Ultimate, but I can still find flaws. The Legend of Zelda: the Wind Waker, Persona 5, Sonic Adventure, and Sonic Adventure 2 are some of my favourite games of all time, but I can find flaws in all of them. No game is perfect, no matter how fun, and it’s important to highlight problems rather than ignore them because “This bit of the game is really cool” in my opinion.

I can agree that the Stage Morphing is brilliant though.

1 2 3

Leave a Comment

Goomba Stomp
Where the cool kids hang.