Connect with us
Nintendo Direct Nintendo Direct


Counter Attack #5: Should Everyone Else Just Copy Nintendo’s Direct?



Counter Attack is a weekly feature here on Goomba Stomp in which John Cal McCormick casts a bemused eye over the gaming news, the niggling issues plaguing the industry, important moments from gaming’s past, or whatever it is that’s annoying him this week. Today we’ll be asking whether everyone should just give up on conferences and rip-off the Nintendo Direct formula?

Nintendo is often described as a company that specialises in innovation, and they’ve certainly earned at least some measure of that reputation. Unquestionably, there’s some innovation going on there at Nintendo HQ, and we owe many of today’s standards in gaming to them and their ideas, but I think people often go a little too far in their readiness to champion Nintendo as gaming’s masters of creation. Quickly perusing some forums and online hide-outs and reading what people have to say about the big N, one could be forgiven for thinking that Nintendo invented, well, pretty much everything.

While to an extent their reputation is earned, true invention has never been one of Nintendo’s strongest suits as far as I’m concerned. As a company, their greatest trait has always been the ability to make fantastic games first and foremost, and then their next most valuable commodity, in my humble opinion, is the ability to take an idea that somebody else has already had and transform it into something that’s more palatable for the masses. While I’m sure that many Nintendo fans would cry foul at the assertion that one of their beloved console manufacturers most desirable traits is similar to that of a scavenger, I don’t think the comparison is an insult at all.

Nintendo’s great achievement with the Wii was never the technology, but in repackaging the technology into a product for mass consumption.

Originality, I think, is an overrated concept. Does it really matter who came up with an idea first? Sure, Neil Armstrong was the first man to walk on the moon, and that’s impressive and all, but if the 400th person on the moon is building a Krispy Kreme up there then frankly, that’s more use to me than a dusty old footprint. Many wonderful products and pieces of art were built on the backs of other creations or feats of originality. I see nothing wrong with celebrating Nintendo’s ability to recognise a hit and then run with it with their own little twists, and it doesn’t matter that it was somebody else’s original thought that got them part of the way there.

Take the Wii, for example. Going by the way that some people talk about the Wii, you’d think that Nintendo invented motion controls. They didn’t. In fact, they didn’t even invent the tech that went into the Wii Remote. They didn’t even have the idea to build a motion controller and then look for tech companies who could build one for them. The concept was invented by some dude named Tom Quinn, who attempted to sell his idea to both Microsoft and Sony who weren’t interested, before ultimately pitching it to Nintendo who took him up on the offer seeing it as a novel design that could revitalise their image after the failed GameCube. Nintendo bought his idea, built a console around it, and then came up with a game – Wii Sports – that was so simple to understand that even your granny could play it – and win. It was ingenious, and it matters not one whit that they didn’t actually do a lot of the legwork in the beginning. They were astute enough to recognise how to improve someone else’s design where other companies, foolishly, were not.

Similarly, where would we be today if Sony hadn’t taken the analogue stick from Nintendo’s N64 controller – which, by the way, Nintendo didn’t invent either – only to add a second one to their pad for camera control? We’d still be controlling our cameras with shoulder buttons, that’s where. And anybody who has gone back and played early PS2 games recently only to discover that they haven’t aged like fine wines can attest to just how important a step forward that second analogue stick being assigned to camera control was, so much so that all three major console manufacturers now offer controllers with a two stick set-up. It’s become the standard for a reason.

The N64 controller sucked, quite frankly, and is mostly useful as a reminder that it’s better to do something properly than to do something first.

If you’re the sort of person that watches press conferences at trade shows like E3 or Gamescom, you’ll have noticed that there’s a sort of accepted standard that each publisher or console manufacturer adheres to, and over recent years, each has made efforts to up their game, refine their act, and make their pressers as entertaining as possible. A corporate suit comes out, dispenses some pleasantries, and then they show a bunch of game trailers, occasionally stopping to talk to a developer or bring a celebrity out for no reason. Rinse and repeat, for an hour or so. Most gaming conferences follow the same basic pattern, and how well the conference goes is generally judged on how interesting the announcements are that they have to make, and how they manage to balance the dev-talk with the explosive trailers.

Nintendo, however, is doing something entirely different to the rest of the pack, and has been for a few years now. The Nintendo Direct is essentially a prerecorded press conference that Nintendo streams at a predetermined date, and people around the world can tune in to watch it. It’s basically a forty minute long infomercial for their upcoming wares, a press conference condensed into just the most salient information. It’s not that they invented the format that is now known as a Direct – other companies have been doing similar things for an age. But they took an idea, made it their own, and it’s gotten to the point where I was watching the conferences at E3 2018 and wondering, “Why isn’t everyone else just ripping off the Nintendo Direct?”

Nintendo’s E3 2018 Direct wasn’t anything particularly special. It wasn’t an especially strong advertisement for the Switch, and there wasn’t an abundance of exciting game reveals or brand new information aside from the twenty minutes or so spent talking about Super Smash Bros. Ultimate. It lacked the razzmatazz of the best E3 conferences, and was actually one of the weakest pressers of E3 2018. But as a format, it was leagues ahead of the competition. It was swift, there was very little down time, there was no awkwardness because it was prerecorded and so they could have as many takes as they wanted to get it right. They had time to tailor their message, and whether you enjoyed it or not, the point is that the delivery method, regardless of how well utilised it was in this case, has a lot of positives over a traditional press conference.

Sony’s E3 conference in 2018 went from musical intro, to gameplay, to intermission, to musical intro, to gameplay, all within the space of twenty badly organised minutes.

Take Sony’s E3 conference, for example. It undoubtedly had more exciting gameplay on show than Nintendo’s Direct, and undoubtedly there’s more high profile games coming to PS4 than to Switch based on what we saw. What we saw, of course, isn’t the whole story as there’s games in development that weren’t shown off, but for the purposes of this point we’ll run with it. They had the content nailed, but unquestionably, the worst thing about Sony’s E3 2018 conference was the conference itself. It was a muddled, badly organised, badly paced, logistical nightmare, that included two musical numbers, an intermission, and a mid-conference venue change that benefited absolutely nobody, from the attendees being herded from one room to another, to the thousands upon thousands watching around the world waiting for Sony to just get on with it and announce some games.

Even if we look at the best conference of E3 2018, which was unequivocally Microsoft’s, we can come to a similar conclusion. There was little awkwardness on stage and hardly any wasted time, but there was also nothing to be gained from performing the presser in front of a live audience. In fact, if we really think about it, barring a handful of crowd pleasing moments like the Final Fantasy VII Remake announcement from 2015, or Sony’s destruction of the original Xbox One DRM policies on stage in 2013, little has ever been improved during gaming conferences by having an audience there, and in fact, the unpredictability of a live show only increases the probability of everything going disastrously wrong.

Microsoft’s 2018 E3 conference succeeded because it was an almost beat for beat recreation of Sony’s 2016 conference, which was one of the greatest of all time. Both pressers shared almost perfect pacing precisely because they cut down on cumbersome moments involving on stage chats with developers ill-prepared to speak in front of large audiences, and were essentially just trailer after trailer after trailer, book-ended by appearances from executives thanking everyone for watching. Comparatively, Nintendo is essentially doing the same thing with their Directs, only they’re sacrificing their ability to conjure rapturous applause from a live crowd in favour of being able to master the pacing, the delivery, the tone, the background music, the entire production of their messaging, without any potential for embarrassing mishaps. Surely, that’s more than a fair trade.

Microsoft’s conference was by far the best of E3 2018, but it wouldn’t have lost a thing by being pre-recorded.

In the age of Netflix and YouTube, a live conference seems in many ways like an outdated concept, a hangover from the days of pre-widely available broadband Internet, and when E3 was reported not live, but in the weeks that followed the event in gaming magazines printed on glossy paper. Those days are long since over, and the general public no longer waits to hear what happened at E3 in print. Today, the general public watch E3 conferences at the same time as games journalists, only instead of being cramped into a hot and sweaty auditorium in LA, they’re sat at home in their pyjamas, enjoying the show in comfort thanks to the power of high speed Internet.

Those watching E3 conferences at home are arguably getting a more enjoyable experience than those in the press who’ve been sent to cover the event, something that I was reminded about while reading about Goomba Stomp’s own attendees at E3 this year, and their disappointing experience at their first trip to the expo. For my part, I was sat at home watching the conferences at my leisure with a chilled beer, and it didn’t cost me a red cent. Other than the ability to play a handful of game demos in busy, noisy rooms, what’s to be gained by anyone actually travelling to E3? Couldn’t we just send out codes for these demos, and let people play the games in an environment that’s more conducive to actually having fun? And more importantly, couldn’t we all just take a leaf out of Nintendo’s playbook, sack off the live conferences, and just deliver a prerecorded broadcast to get the message across more efficiently?

Nintendo is often seen as a backward company when it comes to connectivity on their consoles and there’s a catalogue of good reasons for that, but when it comes to conferences they’re the most forward thinking of our current console manufacturers, having already shed the unnecessary skin of live, on stage pressers in favour of prerecorded announcements that allow them to control every facet of their messaging more deftly.

There isn’t a single press conference that went down at E3 2018 that wouldn’t have been improved by following the Nintendo Direct formula, even the ones that weren’t a train-wreck. Some of the conferences – particularly Sony’s – were nearly derailed because of the delivery method, rather than because of the message they were conveying, and that should never happen. The format of the on stage conference is dated, and in 2018 it feels more redundant than ever, a relic from a time before we all had mobile phones that could stream content in the blink of an eye. Nintendo is ahead of the curve on this, and it would surely make sense for Sony, Microsoft, and video game publishers across the globe to take heed. There’s nothing wrong with looking at something good that another company is doing and being inspired by it. There’s nothing wrong with taking that idea and doing it – or at least trying to do it – better. But there’s plenty wrong with stubbornly clinging to tradition and ignoring progress.

Feel free to leave a comment about this week’s Counter Attack in the comments section below. If you want more from Counter Attack then perhaps check out Ranking The E3 2018 Conferences, or The Rise and Fall of SEGA.

John can generally be found wearing Cookie Monster pyjamas with a PlayStation controller in his hands, operating on a diet that consists largely of gin and pizza. His favourite things are Back to the Future, Persona 4 Golden, the soundtrack to Rocky IV, and imagining scenarios in which he's drinking space cocktails with Commander Shepard. You can follow John on Twitter at

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. Izsak Barnette

    June 25, 2018 at 2:42 pm

    As much as I miss the days of Nintendo doing their live conferences, the Directs and the Treehouse have really have helped to get rid of the awkward moments that used to plague Nintendo’s presentations. After all, who else remembers the disastrous E3 2011 when they unveiled the Wii U? If they would have had a more focused message, who knows if we would have had to live through six years of “Is it a controller or a console?”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *



‘Pokémon Gold and Silver’ Remain the Greatest Pokémon Games



pokémon gold and silver

Editor’s Note: This article was originally published on September 22, 2017.

At last estimate, there were 802 pokémon in the Pokémon World, with Marshadow the latest to be discovered. Back when Pokémon Gold and Silver were released, there was a measly 251 pokémon; an additional 100 pokémon were added for generation two. With so many new dynamics added to the latest Pokémon games, it might be surprising to find that Pokémon Gold and Silver remain the strongest titles in the series, and even more astonishingly, how the successors were influenced more by Pokémon Gold and Silver than they were Pokémon Red and Blue.

It wouldn’t take much convincing to believe that Pokémon Red and Blue was the greatest generation, the original that sparked a highly successful franchise. Indeed, much of what gives Pokémon a strong pay day was soft boiled in generation one. The mascot, after some serious slimming alterations, remains Pikachu, and even the poster boy of the animé, Ash Ketchum, is based on Red from Pokémon Red and Blue. However, when you run from your nostalgia, you’ll find that Pokémon Red and Blue were largely broken.

Pokémon has become a seriously complicated strategy game, that relies on so many complex variables, that becoming a Pokémon Master has never been so difficult. Currently, it remains fairly well-balanced, but it never used to be. Pokémon Red and Blue were terribly flawed when it came to strategy. The Psychic type was ridiculously overpowered, with only weaknesses to Ghost and Bug types, both lacking a strong movepool. The only Ghost moves were Lick and Night Shade, both comparatively weak to your Psychic selection; Bug moves aren’t even worth mentioning. Alakazam became the strongest non-legendary pokémon in the game, something that would cause confusion to the latter addition of pokémon fans.

The Psychic type was controlled in two ways in Pokémon Gold and Silver, a new type and some new moves. No dynamic has balanced competitive play more than the introduction of the Dark type. Suddenly, Alakazam was frail. Umbreon and Tyranitar gave Alakazam some problems it never faced in the previous generation, creating a reluctance to use the iconic Psychic pokémon. Secondly, and most importantly, there were now moves that could do serious damage to Psychic types. Shadow Ball became a new Ghost move that finally did decent damage, Megahorn was introduced as a strong Bug type Move, and Crunch remains a much used Dark type move. To top that off, the split of the Special stat into Special Attack and Special Defence really paralyzed Alakazam into a lightweight pokémon.

It wasn’t just Psychic types that took a hit either, the Dragon type finally had a nemesis with other Dragon pokémon. The reason why Gyarados was never a dragon type was purely down to the balance of the types. A Water/Dragon type in generation one would have only have had a weakness to Dragon, in which the only Dragon move was Dragon Rage which always does 40HP damage regardless of type. The introduction of the move Dragonbreath gave Dragons an actual weakness to the Dragon type, even if the move was relatively moderate in strength. This in return, allowed a Water/Dragon type to be introduced, Kingdra, which is the evolution to the generation one pokémon Seadra.

Kingdra was obtained by trading a Seadra holding a Dragon Scale. This new way of evolving certain pokémon by trade whilst holding an item opened up new evolutions for some generation one pokémon. Onix became Steelix, Scyther became Scizor, Porygon became Porygon2, and Poliwhirl could become Politoed. Two of these were inspired by the introduction of the Steel type, allowing a defensive strategy to blossom in competitive play. Indeed, it’s hard to find a competitive team without a Steel type, with Scizor remaining one of the most widely used.

The pokémon introduced in Pokémon Gold and Silver are some of the most adeptly created designs out of the full 802 pokémon so far discovered. It’s hard to find any seriously awful designs in the generation. The Unowns maybe, but they inspired some differentiation in the same species of pokémon that would end up with Alolan forms in Pokémon Sun and Moon. Baby pokémon were a rather dull, and a particularly needless addition. However, they inspired the most complex dynamic in competitive play to this day, pokémon breeding.

The complexity of pokémon breeding came much later, but the concept remains leech seeded to Pokémon Gold and Silver. Nature and ability, two values that would come in Pokémon Sapphire and Ruby, would spore from the pokémon breeding concept of generation two. Whilst it started as a small gesture to the pokédex to obtain some baby pokémon, it would soon become a pokémon producing factory, often with a Ditto at the center of it, to develop pokémon with the perfect nature and ability for competitive play.

The complexities didn’t end there. Some breeding partners would be able to pass on a move to its offspring that it shouldn’t be able to learn. For example, if a male Dragonite knows Outrage and a female Charizard knows Fire Blitz, the resulting Charmander will know Outrage and Fire Blitz. This could result in a chain effect, whereby a move could be passed on from generation to generation of different species. This helps to give your pokémon a competitive edge by learning a move it wouldn’t be able to learn by normal means.

Pokémon breeding ultimately turned the Pokémon series into very different games. Whilst in Pokémon Red and Blue you had to catch them all, from Pokémon Gold and Silver it started to focus on breeding them all. Filling your pokédex wasn’t just throwing balls and trading, but more complex situations in which your pokémon reacted to the environment. One such change that happened in Pokémon Gold and Silver was the introduction of a night and day cycle. This would continue to feature in every Pokémon generation after that, and Pokémon Black and White would even attempt different seasons. The night and day cycle would be the exact same as the night and day cycle in real life, meaning you had to play Pokémon Gold and Silver at different times of the day to encounter all the pokémon.

This would be further bolstered by certain evolutions only occurring during the day or at night. The most famous, of course, is Eevee into either Espeon or Umbreon. The creation of time and place becoming a factor into the development of your pokémon, plus the divergence of possible evolutions, such as Poliwhirl becoming either Poliwrath or Politoed, gave much more flexibility to how you develop your own team. The evolution of Espeon and Umbreon wasn’t just a time restraint either, but an invisible happiness meter would also play a role. This invisible meter meant for certain pokémon, you just had no idea when they would evolve, you’d only know how to encourage it. This happiness meter would eventually inspire the affection meter in Pokémon X and Y, modeled by another Eevee evolution, Sylveon.

These invisible stats meant, at least for a while, you had to treat your pokémon as if they were a living, breathing creature. Unfortunately, most pokémon that evolve through happiness are baby pokémon, which are incredibly weak. Fainting drops the happiness meter down, so an Exp. Share remains the best way to level it up, should you believe its happiness is high enough for the evolution.

The mathematics hidden beneath each pokémon also created a candy so rare that pokémon fans sought them to this day; shiny pokémon. Not really adding anything to the gameplay other than a different color to your pokémon, some of them look truly amazing. The most sought at the time was always a shiny Charizard, which becomes a beautiful, black dragon. The most famous in the game, however, was the red Gyarados which was part of the storyline.

The storyline itself carried on from Pokémon Red and Blue, something that didn’t really happen in the other generations. In many ways, this made Pokémon Gold and Silver a 90s equivalent to a DLC rather than an entirely new game. This is further shown in the post-game when you can take the S.S Aqua to Kanto and battle the original eight gym leaders to increase your badge total to sixteen. Pokémon Gold and Silver remain the only Pokémon games where you can visit two regions, something that probably won’t happen again.

The intertwined natures of generation one and two are further tied by the animé. In the very first episode of the animé, the legendary bird Ho-Oh is seen flying above Ash. Ho-Oh wouldn’t be seen in the games until Pokémon Gold and Silver, the mascot for Pokémon Gold itself. Likewise, Togepi was seen in the animé well before the release of generation two, hinting at the concept of pokémon breeding by first appearing as an egg. Much of Pokémon Gold and Silver was created in conjunction with Pokémon Red and Blue, creating a natural path to follow on your Pokémon adventure. Since then, the path has become more erratic, with no clear direction. They usually just pick a part of the world for inspiration and create its Pokémon equivalent. The Japanese inspired regions were gone after Pokémon Diamond and Pearl, and way before then, the storyline had lost any kind of direction from one game to the next.

What made Pokémon Gold and Silver so special was it continued the journey already started in Pokémon Red and Blue, and then added the balance that was much-needed competitively. More importantly, it sowed the seeds for future Pokémon games to come, beginning the dynamics we’ve all become accustomed to all the way up to Pokémon Sun and MoonPokémon Gold and Silver is the greatest Pokémon generation because it’s the true origins of the Pokémon games we see today, contrary to the original Pokémon Red and Blue.

Continue Reading

Game Reviews

‘Bee Simulator’ Review: Pleasantly Droning On



Unless a typical bee’s day involves a lot of clunky wasp fights, high-speed chases, and dancing for directions, it’s doubtful many players will walk away from Bee Simulator feeling like they’ve really been given a glimpse into the apian way of life. Sure, there’s plenty of the typical pollen collecting and human annoying here, but odd tasks like hauling glowing mushrooms for ants, helping baby squirrels find their mom, and stinging some little brat who’s stomping all your flowers (hopefully he doesn’t have an allergy) are also on the agenda. That’s not exactly keepin’ it real, but regardless, the variety is actually more simple and less silly than it sounds; it turns out that even doing weird bee stuff quickly becomes repetitive. Still, this family-friendly look at a bug’s life is bolstered by a sincere love of nature, as well as some smooth flight mechanics and a surprisingly large open world for younger gamers to explore.

Bee Simulator beetle

Set in a Central Park-like expanse, Bee Simulator definitely takes on a more edutainment vibe right off the bat (Goat Simulator this ain’t) with a prologue that offers up some info on the ecological importance of bees to the planet. That protective attitude is a constant throughout the game’s short campaign and side quests, as the well-being of these hive heroes is constantly under threat by those goonish wasps, the bitter cold of winter, and of course, oblivious humans. Players take control of a newly hatched worker bee (sorry, drone lovers) who dreams of a role more important than being relegated to merely buzzing by flowers, and consequently sets out to save the day. However, these crises are portrayed in the thinnest terms possible, resolved quickly, and summarily forgotten, leaving little of narrative interest.

So then, it’s up to the gameplay to keep players engaged, and in this area Bee Simulator is a bit of a mixed bag. On the good side, flying works really well, and gives a nice sense of scale to being a little bee in the great, big world. Winging it close to the ground offers a zippy sense of speed, as flowers and blades of grass rush by in colorful streaks. A rise in elevation makes travel seem slower, but provides a fantastic view of the park, showcasing a lakeside boathouse,a zoo filled with exotic creatures, as well as various restaurants, playgrounds, picnics, pedestrians, and street vendors scattered about. Precision is rarely a must outside chases that require threading through glowing rings (a tired flying sim staple) or navigating nooks and crannies, but the multi-axis controls are pretty much up to the task, and make getting around a pleasure.

Bee Simulator zebras

However, that sense of flowing freedom doesn’t quite apply to the limited list of other activities. Though the world is large, the amount of different ways to interact with it is very small, revolving around a few basic concepts: fighting, racing, dancing, retrieving, and collecting. And with the exception of the latter, these actions can only be performed at specifically marked spots that initiate the challenge; most of Bee Simulator exists purely for the view. It’s somewhat understandable in its predictability — how many different things can a bee actually do, after all? — but the gameplay is still a bit disappointing in its shallowness. Fighting plays out like a turn-based rhythm mini-game, those aforementioned races follow uninspired routes, dancing is simply a short bout of Simon, and collecting pollen employs a ‘bee vision’ that does nothing more than verify that players know their colors.

It’s very basic stuff that can’t really sustain motivation for those used to more creativity. The roughly 3-hour campaign seems to support this idea; Bee Simulator knows it doesn’t have much going on for veteran gamers. However, as a visual playground for younger kids to fly around in, free from any real danger, there is something a bit magical about the world presented. There are loads of little vignettes to happen upon, such as a family BBQ, a small amusement park, and a bustling kitchen. What exactly are those lonely row-boaters thinking about out on the lake by themselves? Where is the flower lady going in such a hurry? Discovering new places — like a lush, sprawling terrarium — creates the impression of a massive world with plenty going on regardless of whether the player sees it or not, and can serve to spark the imagination.

Bee Simulator garden

In addition to racking up that pollen for the winter, info on various flora and fauna can also be be collected and stored in the hive’s library, where 3-D models can also be purchased with ‘knowledge’ points earned through completing quests. These texts detail some interesting facts about brave bees and their relation to the environment, and can definitely be a fun teaching tool for wee gamers.

Grizzled fans of the open-world genre may want to buzz clear, however, as well as those hoping for some zaniness. Though Bee Simulator offers some solid soaring in an attractive environment, it’s a sincere, straightforward attempt to promote bee kind that doesn’t offer much more than a relaxing atmosphere and repetitive actions.

Continue Reading


20 Years Later: ‘Pokémon Gold and Silver’ Took the Franchise’s Next Evolutionary Step

The legacy of Johto lives on in what was Game Freak’s next evolutionary step in the world of Pokémon.



Two regions to explore, 16 gym badges to collect, two Elite Four runs to conquer, a battle tower to climb, a previous champion to best at your own game, and 251 pocket monsters to capture. There is no denying that the Johto region of Pokémon Gold and Silver had- and still may contain- the most amount of content to dig into for any player when it comes to everything outside of filling up all the entries of Sword and Shield’s Pokédex.

Pokémon Gold and Silver released in Japan 20 years ago today on November 21st, 1999. The Johto region still stands as not only one of the most renowned Pokémon games in the franchise but a contender for one of the top Game Boy and Game Boy Color games to be released on the handheld systems. No matter which entry is your favorite, there is no denying that Pokémon Gold and Silver was the next evolutionary step on Game Freak’s stairway to fame in what is now currently the largest franchise in history.

A Daunting Next Step

Pokémon Gold and Silver’s development was greenlit immediately after Red and Green had launched in Japan. The untitled sequels at the time were slated for release for the holiday season of 1998. However, during this time frame, Game Freak had also been working on a multitude of Pokémon projects including the Nintendo 64 game Pokémon Stadium and a rebranded companion version to Red that would replace Green for the overseas release of the games. The majority of the small staff team of programmers had already been occupied once the development of Gold and Silver truly began.

What was originally intended to be one year of development slowly turned into three and a half due to a lack of on-hand resources and major programming difficulties that inevitably delayed what was to be the company’s most ambitious release yet. Game Freak found themselves in a troubling situation as the independent company had to balance out time for overseeing the entire Pokémon brand that had expanded into an anime, cards, toys, and even soon to be movies. The worldwide phenomenon was continuing to expand faster than Game Freak could keep up with.

Nintendo Force Magazine – ‘Satoru Iwata Pokémon Tribute’

Late into Gold and Silver’s development, Game Freak’s team of programmers called upon star-man of the industry Satoru Iwata as the developers were having trouble with various coding bugs and fitting all the game assets onto the small memory storage of the Game Boy’s cartridges. Iwata stepped in immediately and saved yet another second-party Nintendo project from disaster. At the beginning of Gold and Silver’s development, Iwata had single-handedly recreated the entire battle system code for Pokémon Stadium by just simply playing the games and analyzing some internal coding. Iwata’s trustworthy knowledge instantly skyrocketed him to become one of the company’s most valuable informants. Nintendo’s future president returned to his all-star team of programmers working at HAL Laboratory to create graphical compression tools for Game Freak to use. This allowed the company to combine both the Johto and Kanto regions onto a single 1-megabyte Game Boy cartridge and meet their latest home territory release deadline.

The Next Phase of Evolution

Gold and Silver continued to build off of Red and Green by introducing the next region in the Pokémon world that would naturally set trends for the series going forward. One of these trends was the reoccurring introduction of a new region inspired by a different area of the world for each game.

Johto was the western half of a landmass shared by the previous game’s location. While Kanto had been based on the Kantō region of Honshu, Japan, the nearby Kansai region would become Johto’s core source of inspiration for its landscape as seen through not only its general location on the map but its architectural features. For example, the sharp shapings of rooftops and gateway entrances to towns known as torii are littered everywhere throughout Johto; some of Kansai’s most common building aesthetics.

Map of Johto and Kanto regions from Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver promotional art

Gold and Silver gained several new features that would ultimately become some of the most crucial and missed aspects of the mainline games. For starters, one important new feature that would solidify its place in future entries was the inclusion of a real-time clock. Multiple in-game events, visuals, and even Pokémon variety in the wild areas would alter depending on the time and day of the week. For example, the psychic owl species of Pokémon, Hoothoot and Noctowl, would only appear in the wild starting in the late afternoon. Eevee could only evolve into Umbreon at night, while the Bug Catching Contest was exclusively available at certain hours on weekdays.

Suicune, Entei, and Raikou became the first trio of legendary creatures to start what is now known as “roaming Pokémon.” Rather than traditionally entering a dungeon-like area, players would randomly encounter these three minor legendaries in the wild grass areas of the game after they had witnessed them book it from the Burned Tower of Ecruteak City during the story. When in battle, the Pokémon will attempt to flee immediately on its first turn. If any of the three are killed in battle, the beast will never be able to appear again on your save file.

The competitive scene for the series would begin to take its modern shape because of the introduction of both breeding and the move deleter. Breeding opened a new floodgate of multiplayer strategies by allowing specific Pokémon to obtain moves they would naturally not be able to learn through technical machines and evolution. Meanwhile, the move deleter finally allowed Pokémon to be rid of their HM moves that previously could not be overwritten, allowing players to freshly design their move-sets at any given time.

The most notable feature, however, would never see a return in a future game. Being able to journey across two different regions is by far Gold and Silver’s most proclaimed component. As stated before, Kanto and Johto share an extremely close geographical connection. Because of this, players can explore the entirety of Kanto after defeating the elite four- more than doubling the amount of content the game had to offer. Outside of the Johto games, this feature has never once returned to another Pokémon game.

The Legacy of Johto Lives On

At the time of its release, Gold and Silver received a highly positive reception from both audiences and critics. The most notable features praised by critics in reviews were the inclusions of more mechanics and typings that deepened the battle system along with the designs of the lineup of new Pokémon receiving all-around praise. During its lifetime on store shelves, the two versions nearly recreated the success of their predecessors as both combined with the sales of their later third enhanced entry Pokémon Crystal sold a total of 23 million copies. Today, Pokémon Gold and Silver are still regarded as some of the best Pokémon games, but not in their original form.

In 2010, trainers had the opportunity to return to the Johto region for the third time in the tenth anniversary generation two remakes Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver for the Nintendo DS. Following in the footsteps of Pokémon FireRed and LeafGreen, the generation two remakes not only attempted to streamline and fix the problems found in the original Game Boy entries of the series but they added a hefty new amount of content for both retuning veterans and newcomers on top of a gorgeous graphical overhaul.

HeartGold and SoulSilver – Cyndaquill partner in New Bark Town

Building off of the engine used for Pokémon Platinum, the enhanced remakes envisioned what is arguably the greatest interpretation yet of the Johto region by continuing to build off what the other DS games had already successfully established. HeartGold and SoulSilver contained nearly every feature found in a Pokémon game up until that point. It sought to continually expand upon modernizing the series through making needed accessibility changes and improving on the Nintendo Wi-Fi connectivity abilities that Diamond and Pearl had a rather shaky start with. Several lost features from previous games outside of Gold and Silver even managed to return for the remake. The beloved idea of having an interactive Pokémon partner to journey around the world with from Yellow, for example, made a comeback but this time any Pokémon could follow you as long as they had been placed in the first party slot.

While still being one of the Nintendo DS’s most commercially successful games, HeartGold and SoulSilver were not able to reach half the amount of sales their original incarnations had achieved. However, the games have averaged the highest critical reception of any mainline Pokémon game released in the franchise. The game notably received spotlight due to its included pedometer accessory the Pokéwalker. The device allowed players to place one Pokémon in the device. As a player walks in real-life, their Pokémon could collect experience, find items, and even catch other creatures that could be transferred directly back into the game.

Pokémon Gold and Silver exclusive MyNintendo 3DS themes.

Today, the original versions of Gold and Silver can be purchased on the Nintendo 3DS Eshop alongside the first Pokémon games- Red and Blue- that had released on the original Game Boy. Alongside the original generation two games, its counterpart successor Pokémon Crystal can also be purchased currently on the Eshop. 3DS home screen themes (as depicted to the left) can also be obtained through gold and silver points through the MyNintendo website.

Continue Reading